Michael
M. Mullin (U.S.A.) - 2001 Wooster Award |
||||||||||||
|
||||||||||||
| PICES Press (2000, Vol. 8, No. 1, pp. 13-17) www.pices.int/publications/pices_press/ |
||||||||||||
|
A biography by David Checkley, Jr. |
||||||||||||
| The Early Years Mike Mullin was destined for a career in science from his earliest time. Born to Joseph and Alma Mullin on 17 November 1937 in the port city of Galveston, Texas, Mike was early to partake in science. From 3-18 months, he was monitored in his crib by his father, a medical researcher, as part of a study of sleep physiology (Fig. 2). Being ‘wired’ may seem commonplace now; in 1939, it was not. Mike endured. He and his family moved to Chicago in
the early 40’s. He continued his involvement in academia at the
University of Chicago Laboratory Schools. Founded in 1896, the Laboratory
Schools allow a child to learn at a rate appropriate for the student,
which apparently was faster than average for Mike.
He graduated after 10th grade at age 15. During his Chicago childhood, Mike was a “Quiz Kid”, competing on the well-known, nationally-broadcast (radio and TV) quiz show (Fig. 3). He apparently was expert in natural history. He also sang in a boys’ choir with his younger brother, Mark, now headmaster of the Casady School in Oklahoma City (Fig. 4). At the age of 15, in 1953, Mike entered the University of Chicago. The following year, he transferred to Shimer College, a rural campus of the University of Chicago, where his father had been appointed President. The liberal arts cirriculum at Chicago and Shimer was grounded in tutorials and readings from primary materials. Modern science was not covered extensively. Hence, after graduating with an A.B. degree from Shimer at age 20, he was admitted to Harvard College as a junior and completed his undergraduate science education. In Cambridge, he also met his wife-to-be, Connie, a Radcliffe student, in a church choir. Mike received a second A.B. degree (with a major in biology) in 1957. Charlie Kennel, present director of the Scripps Institution of Oceanography (SIO), was a Harvard College classmate. Mike’s scholarly association with the ocean may have begun in summer 1958, when he first worked at the Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution (WHOI). This association continued through 1964, when he received his Ph.D. from Harvard. During this period, Mike spent the academic years from 1960-1961 at SIO to broaden his studies in oceanography and statistics, as applied to ecology (Fig. 5). His first publication, with J.W. Hastings in 1962, concerned the size of small plankters. Curiously, this remains a subject of his current research, albeit now on different organisms and with modern instrumentation. The intervening years, however, have seen nearly 70 scientific publications by Mike on a range of subjects. At Harvard and at WHOI, Mike pursued his Ph.D. under the supervision of George Clarke and Bob Conover, respectively. Grazing copepods and their food were his main focus, this being some of the first, quantitative, experimental work on this topic. It was at WHOI, as well, that Mike appears to have established his first trans-Pacific association. Makoto Omori (Tokyo University of Fisheries) was conducting Ph.D. research in the adjacent laboratory of Mary Sears at WHOI. Both graduated in 1964, Mike from Harvard and Mak from Hokkaido University. Curiously, both published their first dissertation papers in the same number of Limnology and Oceanography (1963, vol. 8, no. 3) and both share the same birthdate. Mike joined the International Indian Ocean Expedition
in 1964-65 as an NSF Postdoctoral Fellow, on the R/V Anton Bruun
(Fig. 6), and did further postdoctoral research at the University of Auckland,
New Zealand, studying selective feeding by calanoid copepods. |
||||||||||||
Professor and Oceanographer Following his world travels, Mike returned to the US, moved to La Jolla and SIO, and married Connie in 1964. He remains at SIO today as Research Biologist, Professor, and, since 1989, Director of the Marine Life Research Group. At SIO, Mike developed a strong program of research and teaching and was ultimately ensnared into administration. He was Chairman of the Department of SIO during 1977-80, and Deputy Director and Dean of Academic Affairs at SIO during 1992-1996. Alternate summers from 1966 to 1978 were spent teaching zooplankton ecology with Karl Banse at the Friday Harbor Laboratory of the University of Washington, a formative environment (in a variety of dimensions) for many of his students, including Jed Hirota (Fig. 7). As Director of the MLRG, Mike has also been the UCSD representative on the three-member CalCOFI Committee. The Food Chain Research Group (FCRG), created and led
by John Strickland, was the initial research home of Mike at SIO. It was
with FCRG colleagues that he investigated the plankton off La Jolla and
in the North Pacific Central Gyre (Fig. 8) and the Southern California
Bight. |
||||||||||||
|
||||||||||||
The FCRG effectively disbanded in the 1980s, although
some members remained at SIO, including Angelo Carlucci, Osmund Holm-Hansen,
and Farooq Azam. Mike’s research in those years included the feeding,
growth, production, and distribution of calanoid copepods, their role
in elemental cycles, and a bit on ichthyoplankton. He participated at
all levels of research (Fig. 9). It was during this time that scale, sensu
time and space, became of interest to Mike. He also took a sabbatical
as a Senior Queen’s Fellow in Marine Science at the Australian Institute
of Marine Science, where he worked on salp feeding.
At SIO, Mike continued research on zooplankton ecology, taught courses, and mentored Ph.D. students (~10), postgraduate researchers (~ 5), and numerous undergraduates. His work continued to focus on copepod ecology but expanded also to include trophodynamics and field ecology studies. Several important experiments were conducted in the SIO Deep Tank (3-m diameter, 10-m deep). At one point, wealthy landowners on Mt. Soledad, with views overlooking La Jolla Shores and SIO, were angered when floodlights, used to simulate sunlight by reflecting downward off a large mirror, shone bright in their living rooms at night. Needless to say, experimental protocol was altered. Mike’s office, labs, and research programs have always provided a stimulating, if not illuminating, environment for graduate and undergraduate students, postdocs, and other colleagues. In recent years, Mike’s research has included a renewed interest in copepod egg production and its use to measure temporal and spatial variation in the California Current Region (CCR); zooplankton size distributions and their variation over decades from analysis of historical CalCOFI samples using the Optical Plankton Counter; hake larvae and its food in the CCR; and diatom-nutricline relations off Southern California. Much of Mike’s work of the past decade has been oriented towards a better understanding of the environment affecting young stages of fish. It was written of Mike in 1982,
|
||||||||||||
In fact, Mike has contributed significantly
to studies of plankton pattern in time and space on a variety of scales,
some large. His recent work has, in part, concerned the effects of El
Niño on the zooplankton. Perhaps as, if not more significantly,
he has acted as a guarantor of the 50-year CalCOFI time series.
Mike relinquished his SIO posts of Deputy Director and Dean in 1997 to become Editor-in-Chief of Fisheries Oceanography. This journal was conceived by Tim Parsons and first published in 1992. Under Mike’s leadership, Fisheries Oceanography has continued to gain stature and was recently ranked 11th among fisheries and 15th among oceanography journals. Work of the PICES region is well-represented in this international journal. Mike also authored Webs and Scales (1993), a book based on lectures on fisheries oceanography presented at the University of Washington. Music and Family Music is an important part of Mike’s life at sea (Fig. 10) and ashore. Dave Keeling of SIO founded the UCSD Madrigal Singers in 1963. Tenor Mike became conductor in the late 60’s. Usually performing a capella (unaccompanied by instruments), this group is now known as the La Jolla Renaissance Singers. The two-hour rehearsals are weekly at Mike and Connie’s La Jolla home. |
||||||||||||
|
||||||||||||
This is not for the faint-hearted – prospective members must try out and sight read. Performances are at Christmas, in former years at the Salk Institute and recently at the San Diego Museum of Art, and in the spring in various local venues. Members span four decades of age and have included international visitors from Germany, France, Japan, and elsewhere, as well as distinguished UCSD scientists. When Mike goes to sea, as he still does, a substitute conductor is named. A hallmark of the group is its period costume (Fig. 11). In fact, this costume has transcended the madrigal performances to the podium at UCSD, where Mike regularly lectures 100-200 undergraduates on marine ecology in full regalia (co-professor Paul Dayton does not). This appears to elicit a range of responses from the students, clearly articulated in the range of course evaluations. Concurrent with his scientific interests, Mike has always been very involved in family life. His three children were introduced to music (Fig. 12) and science at an early age. His elder son, Stephen, once “snake-sat” a python of Paul Dayton’s. Stephen Mullin, now Assistant Professor of biology at Eastern Illinois University, is carrying on the family’s involvement in education to the fourth generation. PICES, the Present, and the Future Mike was involved with PICES from its start in 1992. He was the first Chairman of the BIO Committee (1992-95) and served on the first PICES Science Board. Mike convened the first BIO Session on “High Resolution Paleoecological Studies in the Subarctic Pacific” at PICES II in Seattle. He has continued as a US member of BIO and he is on the Local Organizing Committee of the Beyond El Niño Conference.
|
||||||||||||
|
||||||||||||
Mike has had a significant and varied
involvement with scientists from other PICES countries. He has maintained
his relationship with Makoto Omori over the years, hosting Mak as a Visiting
Scholar, with his family, in 1975-76. He participated in the Zooplankton
Symposium in Shimizu, Japan, 1984, in honor of Professors Shigeru Matoda
and Martin Johnson. He was a member of a US-Japan Cooperative Science
Program on zooplankton in the 1980’s (Figs. 13, 14), working especially
closely with Tak Onbé (retired, Hiroshima University). He joined
the 4th International Copepod Conference held in Karuizawain 1990. He
mentored Shin-ichi Uye (Hiroshima University) as a visiting student and
Young-Shil Kang (National Fisheries Research and Development University,
Korea) as a visiting scholar. He was doctoral advisor at SIO for Dr. Hae
Jim Jeong (Kunsan University, Korea).
What are some of the enduring characteristics of Mike? Fairness. Perhaps at times to extremes, he acts impartially, both as scientist and as administrator. Rigor. He is innovative yet his work is thorough, at times sufficiently so as to be difficult to read. Responsible. Mike honors his commitments, usually in a timely manner. MLRG has prospered under Mike’s fiscal and scientific supervision and he continues to contribute vitally to CalCOFI. Bill Bartram, a graduate student of Mike’s, died of cancer in 1979 near the end of his graduate work; Mike alone completed the writing of Bill’s dissertation and saw it through publication in the refereed literature, with Bill as sole author. Mike acted with similar commitment when a foreign visitor to his lab was seriously injured when hit by an automobile, shepherding her through recovery. Scholarly. Mike has a good command of the literature and of the English language, and he puts both to good use in his advising, writing, and, particularly, as Editor of Fisheries Oceanography. Wit. Mike has his moods but, regardless, can show good humor under most circumstances. His publication titles bear witness: “How can enclosing seawater liberate oceanographers” and Webs and Scales. What’s next? There is no mandatory retirement age at UCSD, so it is anyone’s guess. Long-term change in not greatly manifest in Mike’s appearance or actions. He still bikes to and from work, conducts madrigals, lectures in costume, mentors students and postdocs, goes to sea, and researches the zooplankton. No doubt, Mike will continue to contribute importantly to PICES and the fisheries oceanography community in general. This article is written by Dr. David Checkley, Jr.
in appreciation and recognition of Dr. Michael M. Mullin’s outstanding
service to the Pacific Rim scientific community and PICES over many years.
Dave had known Mike Mullin for 29 years. In 1970, Dave took Zooplankton
Ecology from Mike and Karl Banse at the Friday Harbor Labs. Mike was Dave's
major professor at Scripps and a participant in the US/Japan Cooperative
Science Program on Diel Variation in the Physiology and Behavior of Marine
Zooplankton led by Dave and Professor M. Murano (Tokyo University of Fisheries). |
||||||||||||
| Michael Mahlon Mullin, Oceanographer: His Work on Plankton Size and as a Mentor | ||||||||||||
Dave Checkley1, Jr., Jeffrey M. Napp2 and Cynthia T. Tynan3 |
||||||||||||
| 1
Integrative Oceanography Division, Scripps Institution of Oceanography,
La Jolla, CA 92093-0218, dcheckley@ucsd.edu 2 National Marine Fisheries Service, National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, 7600 Sand Point Way N.E., Seattle, WA 98115-0070, jeff.napp@noaa.gov 3 Department of Physical Oceanography, Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution, Woods Hole, MA 02543, ctynan@whoi.edu |
||||||||||||
Mike Mullin (1937-2000, Fig. 1) appreciated
the importance of size in plankton from his earliest to his last days
in oceanography. While a doctoral student at Harvard and the Woods Hole
Oceanographic Institution (WHOI), he investigated the size-based feeding
of copepods of the genus Calanus. While Professor and Director
of the Marine Life Research Group of the Scripps Institution of Oceanography
(SIO) of the University of California, San Diego, he investigated the
relative abundance of small and large plankton in the Southern California
Bight. Throughout his career, Mike taught and mentored students and postdoctoral
investigators, hosted visiting scientists, and conducted his own research
(Fig. 2). His legacy rests in his written works and the work of the individuals
he advised. As three persons who were privileged to work with him, we
comment on Mike as a scientist and a mentor, with the hope that knowledge
of his life may inspire others in the future, particularly students and
young scientists. |
||||||||||||
| Mike and Plankton Size | ||||||||||||
Mike Mullin’s collected publications number 77. Of those, more than a third, 26, including his first and last, concern size in marine ecosystems. His first publication, Hastings et al. 1962, introduced the use of the Coulter Counter as an instrument for sizing and counting particles suspended in seawater. This was followed by Mullin (1963), in which phytoplankton size was shown to affect feeding by four species of the genus Calanus, indicating the generality of size as an important factor in copepod feeding. This paper was a Science Citation Index “Citation Classic” in 1982. On that occasion, Mike wrote “On a less cerebral level, my enjoyment in working with living, aesthetically pleasing, but esoteric aquatic animals was undoubtedly a strong motivation. One referee was unimpressed by the resulting manuscript, but the editor must have given the benefit of the doubt to a graduate student author. Though the electronic particle counters are so easy to use that they have sometimes been employed uncritically, the fundamental importance of particle size in planktonic trophic relations continues to be recognized.” (Current Contents 43:22). While at WHOI, Mike published another classic paper with Sloan and Eppley (Mullin et al. 1966) on the relation of the carbon content of phytoplankton cells to their volume. This relation continues to be used today. Following his Ph.D., Mike joined the Indian Ocean Expedition. He investigated the effect of particle size on feeding by wild-caught copepods, using phyto- and zooplankton he cultured at sea for shipboard feeding experiments. He showed that both plant and animal plankton were consumed by copepods, and deduced that detritus, in addition to living plankton, was of likely importance as well. A series of papers in the late ‘60s and ‘70s concerned the ecology and evolutionary implications of food selection by copepods. On the one hand, Mike demonstrated that copepods select food (or discriminate) when choice exists. However, variation in cephathoracic length often was not accompanied by variation in mouthpart morphology, and copepods were shown to ingest particles of various sizes. Thus, he concluded that feeding selectivity alone does not offer a simple solution to G. E. Hutchinson's (1961) paradox of the plankton, i.e. why apparently similar species often coexist. He further noted the possible effect of plankton size on food webs in papers on deep tank experiments (Mullin and Evans 1974) and models (Steele and Mullin 1977). Mike was impressed by, and impressed upon others, the seemingly endless work required to mimic Mother Nature in the deep tank. That hard work was rewarded in part by a pizza party at the end of the experiment, complete with ctenophore toppings. In the late 1970s, off California, Mike began investigating phytoplankton cell size in relation to both the environment and copepod feeding (Mullin and Brooks 1976, Mullin 1979). He discovered that large (> 5 µm) phytoplankton composed a relatively fixed proportion of phytoplankton retained on Whatman GF/F filters (particles > ~1 µm), an observation that has withstood the test of time and has grown in significance. In addition, there were two noteworthy projects in the Mullin laboratory concerning particle size and feeding. The first was the postdoctoral work of F. Fernandez who examined the nutrition and feeding of Calanus nauplii (Fernandez 1979a, b). He discovered that copepod nauplii also had the ability to discriminate, or select, on the basis of both particle type and size. Nauplii, unlike first copepodites, were unable to ingest either the very small or very large cells. Bartram (1980) helped to define the lower size limit of particles that could be effectively captured and ingested by calanoid copepods. The latter work is noteworthy for its content as well as delivery. William Bartram died of cancer before being able to publish his dissertation research. Mike published it under Bartram's name with only a footnote to explain his role. On sabbatical as a Senior Queens Fellow at the Australian Institute of Marine Science in 1981-82, Mike studied selective feeding by the salp Thalia democratica on bacteria and phytoplankton (Mullin 1983). 3H- and 14C-labeled cultures of each were offered alone and in combination to salps collected and incubated in situ by Mike while SCUBA diving. T. democratica was shown to graze on both food types. This work further demonstrated the value of dual labeling to study particle grazing by marine organisms. Size structure in marine ecosystems can be examined from several different theoretical viewpoints. SIO’s Food Chain Research Group (FCRG) focused on the implied relationship between size and trophic structure (the big eat the small). In 1983, however, the research in Mike's lab took a different tack. A young Fulbright scholar, Dr. Jaime Rodriguez (University of Malaga, Spain), arrived with great enthusiasm, a classical guitar, and a strong background in theoretical marine ecology obtained under the influence of Ramon Margalef’s writings. Jaime felt that classical ecological theory alone could not explain the ecosystem stability and species richness of the North Pacific Central Gyre. He asked if perhaps thermodynamics (à la Prigogine) could offer further insight. This led Jaime and Mike to examine the utility of biomass spectra (Rodriguez and Mullin, 1986a, b). They found the average biomass-size spectrum for mesozooplankton to be log-linear, as expected for a steady state, and the microplankton spectrum obtained from Jack Beers to join the mesozooplankton spectrum. Their application of biomass spectra theory, while not solving the riddle of the North Pacific Gyre, did provide insight into the utility of this approach and described how climate anomalies propagated through the ecosystem. The 80s and 90s were replete with work with others on plankton size, including Mike’s students, Jeff Napp and Alexandra Conversi, who co-authored papers with Mike on grazing by copepods and by euphausiids on phytoplankton assemblages, taking into account particle size as a factor (Napp et al. 1988, Mullin and Conversi 1989). Shannon Cass-Calay, Stace Beaulieu, Erica Goetz - all SIO students -published with Mike on the use of both the in situ and laboratory Optical Plankton Counters (OPCs) for the rapid sizing and counting of larval fish prey (Mullin and Cass-Calay 1997, Beaulieu et al. 1999, and Mullin et al. 2000). He pioneered use of the laboratory OPC for the routine analysis of preserved zooplankton samples. Mike’s last paper published before his death (Mullin 2001), and the antecedent paper (Mullin 1998), once again concerned the relative abundance of small and large phytoplankton. In the first paper, he showed an inverse relation between the proportion of GF/F-retained cells in the >8 µm size class and the nitricline depth, an indication of the availability of new nitrogen to the euphotic zone for non-El Niño years. The latter paper showed that this relation holds for El Niño years as well, and thus is general. The paper in this volume (Mullin et al. 2003) represents Mike’s final work of science. He posed the null hypothesis that the long-term change in macrozooplankton abundance off California during the second half of the 20th century occurred equally among all size classes. As in his first published paper, he again used a relatively new, electronic particle counter, the laboratory OPC. He showed that the size spectrum of California Current macrozooplankton changed over time and thus refuted his null hypothesis.
|
||||||||||||
| Mentoring - Quality Time With Mike (Jeff Napp) | ||||||||||||
Mike wore many hats at Scripps. His
service to the Scripps educational program and administration were as
important to him as his role as mentor. Even with his busy schedule, he
always found time to talk with graduate students about their dissertation
projects. My favorite time was near the end of the day. Sometime late
in the afternoon, after all the committee meetings had ended, after the
phone stopped ringing, after Mike and the old FCRG IBM Selectric typewriter
had reached a truce of sorts, Mike started to unwind. This was a time
that I cherished as a student -- time alone with my advisor. Our conversations
generally stuck to science although life and politics often crept in.
I would always try to be prepared with specific questions to focus the
conversation, but I wouldn't always come away with hard answers or resolve
a particular dilemma. This was because Mike always presented and thoroughly
discussed both sides of an issue and rarely decided (at least in our conversations)
which was "correct." I often came away a little disappointed,
but in hindsight realized that this also was part of the education that
Mike was imparting upon his students -- learning to judiciously look at
both sides of an issue and then deciding for yourself. Perhaps in his
view the arguments were as important as the answers. It is a great lesson,
both in life and science, for few things are ever so clear. A favored
hypothesis we blindly champion today may be tomorrow's dead horse. |
||||||||||||
| Thoughts of Mike (Cynthia Tynan) | ||||||||||||
Mike was a gifted and compassionate listener to many students and colleagues. I often turned to him, as a valued friend and mentor, for advice. Approaching his office with my most recent concern, Mike would smile warmly and prepare to accept his frequent role which he pleasantly termed, as being ‘Father Mullin’. His steady voice, kind nature, and steadfast encouragement to those he believed in, always gave solace. As such, he truly did have a flock of students and colleagues who regularly depended on him for sound and fair judgment. As a critical thinker, his opinion was the one sought by so many. In the world of science, he had a ministry. He dispensed his advice, ideas and wise counsel with grace, kindness and sometimes a raised eyebrow or a twinkle in his eyes. Mike Mullin was one of the most balanced scientists I have ever known, devoted to family and friends, as well as to his science and music (Fig. 3). Calls to his home were always welcome, except on Wednesday night, when he held rehearsal for the La Jolla Madrigal Singers. I can never remember an instance when Mike could not find time to talk to a student. It might be necessary for him to pencil your name into a little pocket engagement book, which he always carried, but somehow he always found time as a mentor. Whether the topic related to experimental design, ethics in science, or personal concerns, he was there to listen and guide as best he could. Quite simply, having Mike Mullin on your side was a wonderful feeling. It still is. A gifted mentor stays with you always. While in discussions with Mike, I was always aware that I was with a dedicated scholar, whose memory of the scientific literature was extraordinary. With surprising speed, he could recall numerous references that would be helpful to your research. I often wondered if he was capable of forgetting anything that he had ever read. He was concerned that, with the modern web-based approach of reference searching, students could handily extract only references published within the past 10 or 20 years, without gaining proper perspective from review of important relevant research conducted 30-50 years ago. Knowing the history of the science and discoveries was as important as knowing the present field. I recall that some of the most pleasant and enjoyable discussions were spent over cups of coffee at the wooden tables under the coral trees in the courtyard that once stood between Ritter, Sverdrup and Old Scripps Buildings. I always emerged calmer, reassured, and better directed, after time spent with Mike. There is little doubt that for so many colleagues and students Mike Mullin was a safe harbor of friendship and guidance. His voice alone had a special quality of supportive warmth. It is his voice that I remember best, and miss the most. |
||||||||||||
| Last Words | ||||||||||||
Charlie Miller, an SIO graduate, wrote, shortly after Mike’s death, “Mike was one of the fraternity of real zooplankton ecologists, the people who know the animals, know a lot about water as a place to live, know the arcane language, understand why anyone would care. A visit to Mike was like being home again, where people really understand what you are saying, what you are all about.” Mike was far more than a scholar. He was truly a mentor, a “close, trusted, and experienced advisor” (Merriam-Webster Unabridged Dictionary, 2000). As technology facilitates our access to information and occupies ever more of our time, to be a scholar and mentor assumes even greater importance. We are confident that Mike would be pleased to know that others now carry on his legacy and that the work he pioneered on plankton size and performed as a mentor can be viewed at the start not the end. |
||||||||||||
| References | ||||||||||||
Bartram, W.C. 1980. Experimental development
of a model for the feeding of neritic copepods on phytoplankton. J. Plank.
Res. 3:25-51. Beaulieu, S. E., M. M. Mullin, V.T. Tang, S.M. Pyne, A.L. King, B.S. Twining. 1999. Using an optical plankton counter to determine the size distributions of preserved zooplankton samples. Jour. Plank. Res. 2110: 1939-1956. Fernandez, F. 1979a. Nutrition studies in the nauplius larva of Calanus pacificus (Copepoda: Calanoida). Mar. Biol. 53:131-147. Fernandez, F. 1979b. Particle selection in the nauplius of Calanus pacificus. Jour. Plank. Res. 1: 313-328. Hastings, J. W., B. M. Sweeney, and M.M. Mullin. 1962. Counting and sizing of unicellular marine organisms. Ann. New York Acad. Sci. 99: 280-289. Hutchinson, G. E. 1961. The paradox of the plankton. Amer. Nat. 95: 137-145. Mullin, M. M. 1963. Some factors affecting the feeding of marine copepods of the genus Calanus. L & O 8: 239-250. Mullin, M. M. 1979. Longshore variation in the distribution of plankton in the Southern California Bight. CalCOFI Rep. 20: 120-124. Mullin, M. M. 1983. In situ measurement of filtering rates of the salp Thalia democratica, on phytoplankton and bacteria. J. Plank. Res. 5: 279-288. Mullin, M. M. 1998. Biomasses of large-celled phytoplankton and their relation to the nitricline and grazing in the California current system off Southern California. CalCOFI Rep. 39: 117-123. Mullin, M. M. 2001. Large-celled phytoplankton, the nitricline, and grazing during the 1997-'98 El Niño. CalCOFI Rep. 41: 161-166. Mullin, M. M. and E. R. Brooks. 1976. Some consequences of distributional heterogeneity of phytoplankton and zooplankton. Limnol. Oceanogr. 21: 784-796. Mullin, M. M. and S. L. Cass-Calay. 1997. Vertical distributions of zooplankton and larvae of Pacific hake Whiting, Merluccius productus, in the California Current system. CalCOFI Repts. 38: 127-136. Mullin, M.M., D.M. Checkley, Jr., and M.P. Thimgan. Temporal and spatial variation in the sizes of California Current macrozooplankton - Analysis by optical plankton counter. Prog. Oceanogr. XXXX. Mullin, M.M., and A. Conversi. 1989. Biomasses of euphausiids and smaller zooplankton in the California Current – Geographic and interannual comparisons relative to the Pacific Whiting, Merluccius productus, fishery. Fish. Bull. 87:633-644. Mullin, M. M. and P. M. Evans 1974. The use of a deep tank in plankton ecology. II. Efficiency of a planktonic food chain. Limnol. Oceanogr. 19: 902-911. Mullin, M. M., E. Goetz, S.E. Beaulieu, J.M. Lasker. 2000. Comparisons within and between years resulting in contrasting recruitment of Pacific hake Merluccius productus in the California Current System. Can. J. Fish. Aquat. Sci. 57: 1434-1447. Mullin, M. M., P. R. Sloan, and R.W. Eppley. 1966. Relationship between carbon content and cell volume and area in phytoplankton. Limnol. Oceanogr. 11: 307-311. Napp, J. M., E. R. Brooks, F.M.H. Reid, P. Matrai, and M.M. Mullin. 1988. Vertical distribution of marine particles and grazers. I. Vertical distribution of food quality and quantity. Mar. Ecol. Prog. Ser. 50: 45-58. Rodriguez, J. and M. M. Mullin 1986a. Diel and interannual variation of size distribution of oceanic zooplanktonic biomass. Ecol. 67: 215-222. Rodriguez, J. and M. M. Mullin 1986b. Relation between biomass and body weight of plankton in a steady state oceanic ecosystem. Limnol. Oceanogr. 31: 361-370. Steele, J. H. and M. M. Mullin 1977. Zooplankton dynamics, p.857-890. In E. D. Goldberg et al. [Eds.], The sea, Vol. 6. John Wiley, New York. |
||||||||||||